The Dead Don’t Hurt (2023): review

Viggo Mortensen’s The Dead Don’t Hurt combines an expansive Western with a tragic love story. Its German theatrical release was on August 8, 2024. Historical circumstances and intimate emotions give the film an interesting tension.

Love in the shadow of the Civil War

In 1860s America, French-Canadian Vivienne Le Coudy, played by Vicky Krieps, falls in love with Danish immigrant Holger Olsen, played by Mortensen. They try to build a life in the small Nevada town of Elk Flats. When the Civil War begins and Holger volunteers, Vivienne is left in a community dominated by corrupt men.

Vicky Krieps between strength and vulnerability

Mortensen writes, directs and stars in his second feature as director after Falling. He shows a strong sense of visual storytelling and emotional depth. Krieps is particularly impressive, bringing both strength and vulnerability to a woman who must stand her ground in a hostile environment.

Landscapes of loneliness

Marcel Zyskind’s cinematography captures the harsh beauty of the landscapes while emphasising the characters’ loneliness and isolation. Locations in Mexico and Canada help create a convincing period setting. The visual scale never entirely displaces the personal story.

Ensemble, music and atmosphere

Solly McLeod, Danny Huston and Garret Dillahunt strengthen the ensemble. Huston’s power-hungry mayor has an especially threatening presence. Mortensen’s music and the sound design support the film’s melancholy, at times oppressive atmosphere, giving its emotional shifts additional force.

A convincing historical world

The production design and costumes contribute to a credible historical world. They help situate the characters within the Civil War period while keeping their individual experiences in focus.

When the story loses momentum

The film is not without weaknesses. Some scenes are drawn out, and the narrative occasionally loses momentum. Strong performances and a dense atmosphere nevertheless keep it engaging. The visual beauty and emotional interest provide reasons to stay with the story when its pace falters.

Verdict

The Dead Don’t Hurt is a solid, visually impressive Western and romantic drama. Its storytelling is uneven, but its performances and atmosphere make it worthwhile. It is a moderate recommendation for viewers who enjoy historical drama and are willing to accept a less consistently paced experience.