Jennifer’s Body had one extremely obvious marketing advantage in 2009: Megan Fox was one of the biggest young stars in Hollywood.
The studio knew exactly what it wanted to do with that. Sell Megan Fox as a sex symbol. Bring young men into theaters. Job done. There was one small complication. That wasn't really the movie Karyn Kusama and Diablo Cody had made.
Underneath the horror-comedy about a possessed high-school girl is primarily a story about two young women whose friendship is intimate, loving, jealous, destructive and deeply unhealthy.
The audience most likely to connect with that perspective was hardly the center of the campaign.
The result was a peculiar act of self-sabotage: the studio successfully sold a version of Jennifer’s Body that wasn't actually playing in theaters.
Megan Fox became the entire pitch
Jennifer is attractive.
The film knows it, and Jennifer certainly knows it. Her effect on other people is deliberately part of the story.
The marketing, however, reduced much of the concept to Megan Fox as an object of desire.
Kusama later described early trailer cuts that omitted Amanda Seyfried, the actor playing the main character. Cody also recalled the studio's insistence on marketing the film to young men. These accounts make the mismatch unusually concrete. The issue wasn't that Fox was presented as sexy. The movie itself deliberately plays with her sexuality.
The problem was the expectation created around it.
Audiences were encouraged to expect a straightforward erotic horror movie and instead got something far more interested in female friendship, dependency, competition, exploitation and the damage men can do around that relationship.
It's a little like marketing Mean Girls almost entirely around Aaron Samuels and then being surprised when someone wants to discuss Regina George.
Jennifer and Needy are the real center of the movie
The most important relationship isn't Jennifer and any of the boys. It's Jennifer and Needy.
They've known each other for years. They love one another and aren't particularly good for one another. Jennifer controls Needy but also depends on her. Needy admires Jennifer while seeing parts of her that other people miss.
The supernatural plot intensifies something that already existed.
Jennifer becomes more dangerous, but the power imbalance in their friendship wasn't exactly healthy beforehand.
That's one reason the movie has become more interesting to later audiences than its original advertising suggested. Jennifer and Needy can be read through friendship, dependency, buried desire or toxic intimacy without the film reducing them to one clean explanation.
The marketing had a cleaner explanation. Megan Fox is hot. Not quite as rich.
The wrong audience gets the wrong movie
Bad marketing doesn't only risk selling too few tickets.
Sometimes the more damaging outcome is putting the wrong audience in the room with the wrong expectations.
Viewers don't judge only what appears on screen. They also react to whether they received the movie they thought they were buying.
Jennifer’s Body therefore had to compete against its own campaign.
Young women, female horror fans and the queer audience that would later become a major part of the film's cult following weren't treated as the obvious center of the release.
At the same time, viewers were heavily targeted who may have had little interest in the perspective the movie actually prioritized.
That's a remarkably efficient way to create disappointment.
Megan Fox arrived with an image the film didn't control
In 2009, Fox's public identity was heavily defined by appearance, sexuality and Transformers. That inevitably shaped the way Jennifer was received.
She could easily be read as a simple extension of that image: the beautiful dangerous woman who seduces men.
Except the movie uses that surface and then turns against it.
Jennifer isn't interesting because boys desire her. What's interesting is what happens to her, how other people use her and how all of it destroys her relationship with Needy.
The character resembles the fantasy the marketing wanted to sell. The film is interested in what exists underneath that fantasy.
The reevaluation arrived with a different audience
Over time, the reputation of Jennifer’s Body changed dramatically.
This isn't simply one of those cases where every initially disliked film has to become a secret masterpiece once enough nostalgia accumulates.
What changed most was the angle from which people approached it.
New viewers encountered the film without the 2009 marketing campaign. Megan Fox was no longer exclusively framed through the same tabloid image, and the movie could be seen more clearly as what Kusama and Cody had actually made.
Suddenly the girls were at the center of the conversation. Remarkable that it took so long for a movie about two girls.
Marketing wasn't the only reason the film struggled initially. Its tone is unusual: horror, comedy, teen movie and deliberately abrasive dialogue all exist at once.
That's precisely why it needed advertising capable of selling that identity. Instead, the campaign promised something simpler. The actual movie was stranger. Years later, that strangeness is one of the reasons Jennifer’s Body has become a cult film.
The studio had something very marketable in its hands.
It just kept trying to market a different movie.
Watch the film at home
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Using these links does not add to the price you pay.