In The Others, the curtains aren't decoration. They're a rule.
Grace lives with her children Anne and Nicholas in a large isolated house. Both children are extremely sensitive to light, so rooms must remain dark, doors must be closed and movement through the house has to follow a strict system.
Alejandro Amenábar takes that practical story rule and builds almost the entire film around it. Darkness controls what the characters can see, how they move and which information remains hidden. More importantly, light represents both danger and discovery for Grace.
That's an uncomfortable contradiction.
Grace needs rules
Grace runs her household with almost military precision.
No door is opened until the previous one has been closed. Curtains stay shut. Keys have defined purposes. The servants are expected to follow procedures.
On the surface, it makes sense. Her children can't be exposed to sunlight. The rules also tell us a great deal about Grace. She isn't only protecting Anne and Nicholas. She's trying to keep her entire world controllable.
The house becomes a system in which everything has an assigned place.
Religion serves a similar purpose. Grace has fixed answers for almost every question and passes them on with complete confidence.
Uncertainty doesn't suit her. Unfortunately, haunted houses rarely adjust themselves around personal preference.
Darkness protects them and prevents knowledge at the same time
Amenábar has described the children's light sensitivity as a metaphor. Light is knowledge. Darkness reflects Grace's limited perception and rigid worldview. The elegant part is that the metaphor isn't sitting beside the plot. It is the plot.
Grace literally has to keep light out of the house to protect her children.
At the same time, she's excluding the symbol of knowledge.
The more aggressively she keeps the world dark and controlled, the longer she can avoid understanding what that world actually is.
Efficient.
Some movies need a professor to discover an ancient book and spend twenty minutes explaining the theme.
The Others needs curtains.
Darkness makes the house feel larger
The lack of light also controls the filmmaking.
The house contains room after room, corridor after corridor, doors and staircases, yet we're never certain what lies beyond the next patch of darkness.
Amenábar doesn't need to fill those spaces with visible ghosts. Emptiness is enough.
A noise in another room becomes important because the characters can't immediately see what caused it. A doorway becomes threatening because something could be beyond it. A curtain carries more dramatic weight than monsters receive in plenty of other horror movies.
The audience has to work with the same limited information as Grace. We see what she can see. That becomes rather important later.
Spoilers: detailed film discussionIncludes plot developments and the ending. Open deliberately.
Grace believes she's defending the house
Much of the horror comes from Grace's conviction that intruders have entered her home. Voices can be heard. Objects move. Anne claims she's seen other people. Grace responds exactly as we'd expect a character in a traditional ghost story to respond.
She wants to identify the threat and remove it.
The problem is that her fundamental assumption is wrong. In a much more complicated sense, the house isn't hers anymore. Darkness therefore gains another meaning in retrospect. It hasn't only concealed what's inside the house. It has concealed what Grace herself is.
The revelation that Grace and the children are themselves dead is stronger than a simple surprise because the film doesn't suddenly declare everything we watched irrelevant.
The opposite happens. The rules acquire new meaning.
The “intruders” are the living inhabitants of the house. The séance belongs to their side of reality. The strange voices and movements weren't random supernatural decoration.
Each group believed the other was haunting the house. That's far more elegant than introducing a brand-new explanation five minutes before the credits.
Light is no longer the same enemy
Grace's journey is therefore genuinely a movement toward knowledge.
She can't accept the truth because it contradicts the entire system through which she understands the world. Religion, routine and control can delay the realization but can't prevent it forever.
Eventually she has to understand what happened. Darkness doesn't simply disappear afterwards. Its meaning changes.
That's why The Others feels so carefully constructed. The children's condition isn't an excuse to make a ghost movie look attractively dark.
It connects plot, character, theme and visual design. Grace keeps the light outside. For a very long time, she keeps the truth outside with it.
Watch the film at home
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Using these links does not add to the price you pay.